(From the Geneva Times, June 27, 1959)
By E.T. Emmons
American history is complex, and the ways we interpret it continue to evolve. As part of our yearlong celebration of America’s 250th birthday, we will be sharing local histories written by community members. While these materials reflect the times in which they were written, they remind us that how history told is also part of history.
E.T. Emmons (1906-1971) was the city editor (1906-1945) and executive editor (1945-1971) of the Geneva Daily Times. In addition to his “Day of Yore” column, he wrote The Story of Geneva (1931).
The recent visit of Dr. Max Beer, a Swiss newspaper correspondent now residing in New York City, again brings to the front the question how Geneva got its name.
Dr. Beer, exploring the various angles of possibility, was actuated by a desire to write an article about Geneva, NY for perusal of the people of Geneva, Switzerland, where he lived for many years.
The question has been dealt with several times in this series. Since it still remains not entirely satisfactorily answered, it seems appropriate to go into the question in a little more detail.
One thing seems certain. The name Geneva was not bestowed upon this settlement in the wilderness by Captain Charles Williamson, agent for the Pulteney Estate, who did not come to this country until 1792. The place had been referred to as Geneva a number of years previous to that date.
How Geneva got its name has perplexed local historians from an early date.
Back in December 1891, George S. Conover, Geneva’s leading historian undertook to disprove the belief that Capt. Charles Williamson named the place Geneva because of its resemblance to Geneva, Switzerland. He called attention in a letter sent to the Saturday Review that the place has been referred to as “Geneva” several years before Capt. Williamson ever set foot here in February 1792.
Mr. Conover appends the exact text of several letters and other documents of date earlier than 1792, in which the appellation “Geneva” is used, to prove his point…
The letters and documents referred to by Mr. Conover were as follows
- Letter to Dr. Caleb Benton to William Walker, agent for surveys and sales of Phelps and Gorham, Geneva, Oct. 15, 1788. The original letter, together with No. 3 can be found parted in the back part of Vol I, Village Records.
- Contract, 28th October 1788, between William Walker and John Dk’r Robinson, by which “Robinson doth agree to build for the said Walker a house at Canandaigua of the same dimensions and in the manner as the house now building by Captain Battles at Geneva with this variation,” etc.
- Letter of Enos Boughton, Geneva. Nov. 7, 1788, to Wiliam Walker
- Hiccock’s receipt for goods stored for the winter at Geneva, dated Geneva, Nov. 24, 1788.
- Two certificates of Benjamin Allen giving up contract for land both dated Geneva, June 24, 1789. Also two of same date by Eleazor Lindsly and Benjamin Allen.
- Letter of Major Abraham Hardenbergh, July 5, 1789, to the surveyor general, published in Hough’s Indigenous Peoples Treaties, the original to be found in the state library number being No 6034 of the Mss. Papers of Gov. George Clinton.
- Bill of Elisha Tallmage against William Walker, Oct. 5, 1790…
- “Map of the Genesee Lads in the County of Ontario and State of New York according to an accurate survey which was made of the same 1790.”
- Journal of Alexander Coventry, MD in which Geneva is named under date of July 6, 1791.
- Journal of Elkanah Watson, describing his visit to Geneva, Sept. 20, 1792.
Another Geneva historian who made a deep research into the matter of the origin of the name was George M.B. Hawley.
It was conceded by Mr. Hawley that in some manner there may have been an early association of the name of the new settlement here with Geneva Switzerland, as he says “because of the similarity of landscape upon the lake,” but he never was able to satisfactorily establish the point.
However, he was most emphatic in refuting the tale that the name Geneva was the supplied by a Swiss engineer in the employ of Charles Williamson, and has produced several pieces of documentary evidence of support the statement that the place was referred to as Geneva several years before Williamson came here.
Two letters cited by Mr. Hawley were written in 1788, one on April 23 and the other on Mov. 28. Both were date lined as from “Geneva.” Both pertained to matters of the Leasee Company. The one dated Nov. 28 is signed by Caleb Benton, also author of two other letters proving the same point, one addressed to William Walker, the first land agent of Phelps and Gorham, at Walkersville (Canandaigua). Both letters are headed “Geneva” and were written in 1788.

Still another Geneva, historian Dr. Ulysses P. Hedrick, former director of the N.Y. State Experiment Station, credits Horatio Jones, early fur trader, with having changed the Seneca name “Kanadesaga” to “Geneva” as early as 1785. This statement was made in an address delivered by Dr. Hedrick to a session of the NY State Historical Society held here in 1941. His authority for this statement, however, is not quoted. However, the fact that Jones is reported to have had dealings with the John Jacob Astor fur-trading company at that early date does seem to supply some additional credence to the allegation that the place may have been designated “Geneva” by the fur company.
Geneva’s first settler Elark Jennings, who established himself at an early date, perhaps as early as 1785 or ’86 on the lake front “under the hill” is alleged to have sent a letter or letters out of here at about that time, dated “Geneva.” There was only a small trading post here at that time and a favorite acceptance of fact by later-day historians is that the location was thus designated by the Astor Fur Trading Co., as one of its outposts, names of European cities and capitals having been chosen for the purpose of supplying names to their outposts.
If Captain Williamson had any part in helping affix the name Geneva to this location it must have been through his acceptance of the appellation after he came here in 1792 and recognized the similarity between the village site here and the city of Geneve in Switzerland, which he is said to have visited in his travels about Europe.
Actually, says Historian Conover, the settlement was for some time referred to as Kanandesaga, also the name of the Seneca stronghold just west of the present city. The name Kanandesaga, says Mr. Conover, was bestowed by the Seneca not only on their own settlement but also upon the creek, the lake, the outlet, and at a subsequent date it was also transferred to Geneva. At that time the old location of the Seneca village was referred to as the Old Castle…..
Another early visitor to this part of the country in the fall of 1791, and who used the name Geneva freely in his diary, was Elkanah Watson, a great traveler of the period and who kept a close record of his journeyings, which have been frequently quoted. It was on Sept. 20, 1791, that the Watson party approached Geneva and his journal on the 21st records that date records: “The new village of Geneva made its appearance in the northwest part of the lake, to which we directed our course, after disentangling ourselves from a hard sand bank at the outlet of the lake.”
The next day, he was in Geneva and of that experience writes:
“Geneva is a small, unhealthy village, containing about fifteen houses, all log except three, and about twenty families. It is built partly on the acclivity of a hill and partly on a flat with deep marshes north of the town, to which is a tributed its unhealthiness. We received decent accommodations at Patterson’s on the margin of the lake, but were troubled the most of the night by gamblers and fleas, two curses to society.”
This passage from Watson’s diary has been quoted frequently and already has occurred in this series of histories. It is repeated here expressly for the purpose of indicating that Watson used the name “Geneva” gibly as early as 1791, a full year before Captain Williamson every stepped foot into the community. It also does provide a somewhat graphic picture of the early settlement, which by no stretch of the imagination could be found closely resembling the already beautiful old city of Geneva, Switzerland, save for its generally comparable lake location, which still may in some manner have been the basis for the designation.
To further, establish the connection of John Jacob Astor with early Geneva let us turn for a moment to the biography of that immigrant to America who became one of the country’s first multi-millionaires.
Astor was born on July 17, 1763 in the village of Walldorf, near Heidelberg, Germany. It was in 1783 that he migrated to this country and settled in New York. On the voyage to America he became acquainted with a fur trader, by whose advice he devoted himself to the same business. By his energy and enterprise he speedily amassed a large fortune. He devoted many years to organizing the fur trade throughout the whole country. When he died on March 29, 1843 his fortune was estimated at $30,000,000.
These facts and dates bear out the tradition that it was his company that was operating on Seneca Lake at about the time the first settlers came here, and indeed, it is stated in one history (McIntosh’s) that Horatio Jones, one of the earliest comers to the pioneer settlement, sold his first lot of furs to the Astor company. The fact remains to be accurately established that the Astor fur company did designate this trading post as Geneva, for one reason or another, perhaps for its location on a lake, as Geneva, Switzerland. It is said, however, that such trading posts were named in this manner, which gives considerable reason to believe that here, indeed, was the origin of the name as applied to the early settlement and later, to the village and the city.
Additional facts in support of the tradition that Geneva got its name originally by being a fur trading post thus designated by the Astor Fur Company can be found in a biography of John Jacob Astor, published by James Parton in 1865.
This account of the life of America’s first great millionaire related that Astor went into the fur business for himself in 1786, which is about the first date of which there is any record that this settlement was called Geneva. Previous to that Astor had been associated with Robert Bowne, another fur trader, and while learning the business made frequent trips into the wilderness buying furs from Indigenous People and from the settlers.
Later, on his own, he continued to make journeys into the interior of the state, with which he became very well acquainted. Parton says he collected skins from house to house, “gradually extending his travels, till he knew the state of New York as no man of his day knew it….”
Parton makes no direct statement that would further substantiate the claim that Western New York fur trading post were named after European cities but the possibility is not be to entirely discounted.
Neither is there any statement in Parton to the effect that Astor himself came here to Geneva, although it also is quite likely, Parton does cite an incident in which General Wadsworth (presumably from Geneseo) once met Astor in the woods of Western New York in a sad plight, his wagon having broken down in a swamp and his gold having been spilled through the bottom of the vehicle and irrevocably lost. This, at least, would indicate that Astor penetrated into the wilderness even further west from Geneva, and thus may have visited here, calling on the traders who early established themselves on the shores of the lake.
(Author’s Note: It is not desired here to build up another tradition concerning Geneva and its origin, which may be unfounded. It is desired only to call attention to a possibility, even a probability, still unsupported by direct evidence. It would be nice to have it proven conclusively.)
This article was brought to you in part by our supporters. Be our partner in telling Geneva’s stories by becoming a Historic Geneva supporter.